• News
  • The Institute
  • Fellows
  • Projects
  • Science & Society
  • Event facilities
  • Archive
    • News
    • Events
    • Press releases
    • Press review
    • Newsletter

Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften

Am Wingertsberg 4
61348 Bad Homburg v.d. Höhe
Tel.: 06172/139770
E-Mail: info@forschungskolleg-humanwissenschaften.de
 
How to find us
Legal notice
Data protection declaration
  • Home
  • Archive
  • News
  •  Print 
Pro-Democracy Protests in Israel: An Evening of Discussion at the Kolleg
Fellows Daniel Statman and Cain Shelley brought philosophical and political science perspectives to bear on the recent protests


From the left: Cain Shelley and Daniel Statman (photo: Stefanie Wetzel)

For some six months now, the Israeli population has been protesting against the government’s planned judicial reform, which threatens the very foundations of the country’s democratic government. The overwhelming participation in the ongoing protests gave Daniel Statman, professor of philosophy at the University of Haifa, the idea of initiating an evening of discussion at the Kolleg. Professor Statman began by explaining the background to the protests in the respective positions of the government and the protestors. He and Cain Shelley, a fellow at the Forschungskolleg working on political activism and questions of social justice at the Justitia Center for Advanced Studies, made the following points regarding the protests:

1. According to Daniel Statman, the protests were directed not least against the steadily increasing power of an ultra-orthodox and in parts far-right minority in Israel. Does this mean that the protests can be understood as expressing the crisis of liberal democracies in the present?

2. Although the protests are non-violent, protestors have repeatedly gathered for demonstrations outside the private residences of government politicians, taking the protests into their private spheres. What are the limits of legitimate protest in a democracy?

3. The protests have brought together large sections of the population in a single movement. This means that debates over other divisive issues—notably Israeli settlement policy—have been put aside for the duration. But can a protest succeed if it ignores conflicts that are potentially dangerous to peaceful coexistence within a liberal democracy?

There followed a discussion, in which guests and other fellows of the Forschungskolleg sought to apply this conceptual framework to understanding and contextualizing current events in Israel.

A small victory for the protestors, followed by a disappointment
The Forschungskolleg discussed the situation on Monday, June 26. Soon after, on June 26, Benjamin Netanyahu’s government announced that the judicial reforms would be implemented only in part, deleting the provision whereby the Israeli parliament was entitled to overrule judgments of the Supreme Court.
On July 10, parliament voted on another part of the judicial reform, which includes a provision that the country's Supreme Court will no longer be able to judge a government decision as »unreasonable«. The bill was approved by parliament in its first reading. The protest movement fears that this will encourage corruption and thus arbitrary appointments to high-ranking posts.

A detailed account of the discussion (in German)
»Die Ethik des Protests«
UniReport der Goethe-Universität Frankfurt, No. 4, 06.07.2023, p. 20.
(Read article)


(FKH - 11.07.2023)
In order to provide you with the best online experience this website uses cookies. Delete cookies

By using our website, you agree to the data protection declaration and to the use of cookies. Learn more

I agree

Information cookies

Cookies are short reports that are sent and stored on the hard drive of the user's computer through your browser when it connects to a web. Cookies can be used to collect and store user data while connected to provide you the requested services and sometimes tend not to keep. Cookies can be themselves or others.

There are several types of cookies:

  • Technical cookies that facilitate user navigation and use of the various options or services offered by the web as identify the session, allow access to certain areas, facilitate orders, purchases, filling out forms, registration, security, facilitating functionalities (videos, social networks, etc..).
  • Customization cookies that allow users to access services according to their preferences (language, browser, configuration, etc..).
  • Analytical cookies which allow anonymous analysis of the behavior of web users and allow to measure user activity and develop navigation profiles in order to improve the websites.

So when you access our website, in compliance with Article 22 of Law 34/2002 of the Information Society Services, in the analytical cookies treatment, we have requested your consent to their use. All of this is to improve our services. We use Google Analytics to collect anonymous statistical information such as the number of visitors to our site. Cookies added by Google Analytics are governed by the privacy policies of Google Analytics. If you want you can disable cookies from Google Analytics.

However, please note that you can enable or disable cookies by following the instructions of your browser.

  • English (UK)
  • Deutsch
 
All news | All events
Impressionen

On June 26, 2023, Cain Shelley and Daniel Statman discussed the current pro-democracy protests in Israel with guests and the interested public from a philosophical and political science perspective.
more...
Events | FKH

19 October 2023
Lecture (in German)
Ulrich Willems (Universität Münster): »Der Kompromiss. Theorie und Praxis einer Konfliktregelungstechnik«
more...
News

FKH video
Lecture | »The Neo-Avant-Garde and the ›Future‹ of China’s Literary ›Past‹« | Fangdai Chen
more...
Just published
Newsletter of the Forschungskolleg Humanwissenschaften (Summer Semester 2023)
more...
Goethe Fellows
Christoph Burchard Appointed Founding Director of the Center for Critical Computational Studies
more...
Goethe Fellows
Sabine Andresen Elected New President of the German Society for the Protection of Children
more...
Retrospective
Pro-Democracy Protests in Israel: An Evening of Discussion at the Kolleg
more...
Photos, video, article in UniReport
Sigmar Gabriel delivers second John McCloy Lecture
more...